Appendix 5 - Equality Impact Assessment

1. Service affected

Answer

Rent it Right – Selective Licensing Scheme

2. Relevance to equality

You need to make clear if the policy/function is highly relevant, relevant or not relevant to equality. To determine relevance to equality you need to complete the ‘Checklist for determining relevance to equality’

Please detail which groups are most affected. 

Answer

We will monitor equality data through customer surveys. The expected outcome is knowledge of equalities characteristics of Landlords and Tenants.

  • highly relevant to equality
  • the proposal is particularly relevant to the protected groups of race and disability

3. Potential savings

Please detail the proposed savings to budget that you are hoping to make.

How will this be achieved? 

Answer

Not applicable.

4. Policy/service proposal

You will need to detail the following:

  • Please provide a profile of the service including its purpose, how and where the service is delivered and who uses it
  • What are the specific changes that you are proposing and what will these changes deliver?
  • Are these proposals just linked to savings or is there a solid business case for this? Please detail
  • How will this change support our wider objectives such as the Corporate Plan or directorate business plans?
     

Answer

Local Authorities have a discretionary power to introduce licensing for privately rented properties accommodating single households. Part 3 of the Housing Act 2004 sets out the scheme for licensing private rented properties in a local authority area. Under Section 80 of this Act, a local housing authority can designate parts of its area as being subject to selective licensing.

The London Borough of Bexley introduced a selective licensing scheme on the 1st October 2018 which was applied in four defined areas in the north of the Borough, covering Thamesmead, Lower Belvedere, Erith and Manor Road.

The intention of the scheme is to improve conditions for the most vulnerable tenants and provide further regulatory control of the private rented sector. The identified areas evidenced high levels of private renting coupled with high levels of anti-social behaviour (ASB) when compared to national and borough averages.

The scheme is a proactive approach that resolves the issue of relying entirely on complaints to flag issues; will improve conditions for the most vulnerable tenants and provide further regulatory control of the private rented sector. It is important that we ensure landlord compliance with the licensing scheme and that we take the necessary enforcement action to ensure properties that require a licence are licensed.

Benefits of using a selective licensing scheme

The designation of these areas identified as subject to the selective licensing scheme means:

  • improved control over the use and management of privately rented housing in the areas identified as the most problematic in Bexley
  • provided a means to improve the condition and management of rented properties in areas with the highest levels of ASB and highest proportion of private rented properties in Bexley
  • provided a means to target and improve poorly managed property

In addition to these benefits the introduction of the scheme and the conditions that landlords are required to comply with, improves other important aspects of private renting in Bexley such as:

  • improve the living conditions for all tenants including the most vulnerable who do not come forward to make complaints
  • improve the Council’s relationships with landlords
  • provide more help, support and education for landlords
  • encourage landlords to provide better quality accommodation
  • encourage and require landlords to be better informed about their legal duties and responsibilities towards their property and tenants
  • encourage and support more landlords to become and remain accredited which will improve property standards and management
  • better inform tenants about their rights and responsibilities
  • reduce ASB and promote safe attractive neighbourhoods
  • crack down on rogue landlords
  • raise the profile of private renting in Bexley to make it more attractive and accessible to everyone
  • improve data on the private rented sector in Bexley to enable the Council to be better informed and proactive in its decision making and in designing and promoting initiatives to support landlords and tenants

The introduction of the licensing scheme supports the Council in meeting the aims of the Housing Strategy 2020 to 2025 and supports our Bexley Plan 2022 to 2026, which is our vision for the borough. The introduction of the selective licensing scheme links into and directly supports a stated aim of the Bexley Community Safety Partnership Strategy 2022 to 2025 to tackle identified anti-social behaviour.

Enforcement of selective licensing scheme:

  • over the duration of the scheme, there were 2,104 (86%) applications out of the estimated 2,451 licensable properties within the selective licensing areas
  • the Council investigates unlicensed properties through a combination of its own data and complaints received from tenants and neighbours. Where landlords fail to licence a property, the Council can either prosecute the landlord or issue a civil penalty notice (CPN). Income received from the payment of a Civil Penalty Notice can be retained by the Council provided that it is used to further our statutory functions in relation to enforcement activities covering the private rented sector. 23 Civil Penalty Notices have been issued for failure to licence properties in Bexley since the scheme began
  • the Council has inspected 310 properties within the selective licensing scheme. In total, 220 of these properties had at least Category 1 and 2 hazards that were removed by either formal or informal action
Proposed new selective licensing scheme

As selective licensing schemes are time-limited to five years and Bexley’s current scheme ended on 31st August 2023, the proposal is to designate a new selective licensing scheme within the Belvedere ward.

The main aims for introducing a new selective licensing scheme in the Belvedere ward would be to address ASB and Property Conditions (i.e., to reduce gas/mould/damp/fire hazards within the property) within the privately rented sector, bringing the benefits referred to earlier in this section. The reasons for why Belvedere ward has been chosen are set out in Section 6

5. Impact on equalities groups

Please detail the likely impact of your proposals on each equality group including service users and potential service users, supported by demographic evidence.

The equality groups are 

  • Age
  • Disability
  • Sex
  • Gender reassignment
  • Pregnancy and maternity
  • Race
  • Religion or belief
  • Sexual orientation
  • Marriage and civil partnership (but only for aim one of the duties)

You will need to consider these impacts in relation to the duties detailed under the Public Sector Equality Duty. What evidence do you currently have about who uses this service, how important is this service to each equality group and the likely impact of your proposals on each equalities group?

You will be expected to use demographic information to show the composition of the service users in each of the equality groups. If we do not have such information, please state the group and that no information is currently recorded.

Answer

Protected characteristic

Age

Analysis

The licensing schemes provide advice and guidance as well as an enforcement element, and the advice and guidance should be of value to landlords of all ages, especially those who may be anxious about complying with new regulations. 
Within the Housing Health and Safety Operating System (HHSRS) operating system the vulnerable age group for falls and excess cold hazard are over 65’s. We would expect the scheme to remove these hazards from PRS properties. This will lead to improvements to properties where elderly residents are living.

The application form is online. We do have elderly landlords contact us who have difficulties completing the application form. In those instances, we have provided assistance with completing the application form, by talking them through the form over the phone or in-person.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Disability

Analysis

15% of Bexley’s population has a disability or long-term condition that limits their day-to-day activities (2021 Census). We do not know the proportion of landlords or tenants with a disability.
There is no known impact on landlords who have a disability, except assistance is available by phone and email from a council officer for those having difficulty using online application and payment systems.
Tenants with disabilities are more likely to be impacted by cold and issues such as no heating or hot water.  The scheme should lead to improvements in their living conditions. There is no known impact on tenants who have a disability.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Gender reassignment

Analysis

In Bexley, over 1,000 people answered in the 2021 Census that they did not identify with their registered sex at birth. (The population proportions were similar to that for England & Wales); 5.7% did not answer the question, 93.8% answered that they identified with the same sex as birth and 0.5% answered that they did not identify with their registered sex at birth. The breakdown of gender identity is also similar to that for England & Wales. 
There is no known impact on landlords or tenants who have gender re-assignment, except that one of the benefits of licensing schemes is to reduce the incidence of harassment of tenants by landlords or attempts by landlords to unlawfully evict tenants.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Marriage and Civil Partnership

Analysis

46% of Bexley residents aged over 16 are married or in a civil partnership. (2021 Census) 
We do not know this information for either landlords or tenants.
There is no known impact on landlords or tenants due to marriage or civil partnership, except that one of the benefits of licensing schemes is to reduce the incidence of harassment of tenants by landlords or attempts by landlords to unlawfully evict tenants.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Pregnancy and Maternity

Analysis

There is no known impact on landlords or tenants due to pregnancy, except that one of the benefits of licensing schemes is to reduce the incidence of harassment of tenants by landlords or attempts by landlords to unlawfully evict tenants.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Race

Analysis

According to the 2021 Census Data. The ethnic group profile of Belvedere shows that Belvedere is a lot more diverse than Bexley has a whole. Over a half of Belvedere residents have an ethnic background that is not white British, compared to just over a third for Bexley as a whole.

Black African residents account for 15.5% of the Belvedere population compared to 9% for the rest of the borough (9.4% Bexley as a whole) – a 6.5 percentage point difference.
Residents with ‘other white’ ethnic backgrounds account for 10.4% of the Belvedere population compared to 5.7% for the rest of the borough (6% Bexley as a whole) – a 4.7 percentage point difference.

Many other ethnic groups were a higher proportion of the Belvedere population compared to the rest of the borough. Several of the Asian ethnic groups had a lower proportion except for Indian and ‘Asian other’ - but when grouped up to ‘Asian’ there is still a higher proportion of ‘Asian’ residents in Belvedere when compared to Bexley as a whole or the ‘rest of Bexley’.

There is no known impact on tenants due to race, except that one of the benefits of licensing schemes is to reduce the incidence of harassment of tenants by landlords or attempts by landlords to unlawfully evict tenants. Landlords in providing a service are not allowed to discriminate against tenants or prospective tenants for any protected characteristic including race.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Religion/Belief (Including Non-belief)

Analysis

There is no known impact on landlords or tenants due to religion or belief, religious information is not collected for landlords except that one of the benefits of licensing schemes is to reduce the incidence of harassment of tenants by landlords or attempts by landlords to unlawfully evict tenant.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Sex

Analysis

Many women work as landlords, letting agents and property managers. There is no known impact on landlords or tenants due to gender.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive


Protected characteristic

Sexual orientation

Analysis

2.11% of the population aged 16 and over identified with an LGB+ orientation. There was around 2,000 gay or lesbian, 1,500 bisexual, 350 pansexual and 150 asexual, queer or other sexual orientations (Over 4,000 people). (2021 Census Data)
This information is not collected for our landlords or tenants. 
There is no known impact on landlords or tenants who identify with an LGB+ orientation, except that one of the benefits of licensing schemes is to reduce the incidence of harassment of tenants by landlords or attempts by landlords to unlawfully evict tenants.

Impact (positive, negative, neutral)

Positive

6. Supporting evidence about why a change is required?

What is the context to the proposed change in policy/function? Please concisely describe the relevant background/context as to why the change is being proposed.  For example, is there national guidance that promotes the change? Best practice? Credible independent research about the outcome being sought? Financial situation of the service/Council?

Is this proposal likely to be subject to a public consultation with service users and potential service users? Please state when consultation is/was carried out and give overview (including whom consulted; different methods used to make sure relevant people asked; issues raised by people and action taken on any of these issues – did we change anything in relation to the consultation feedback?)

Answer

Evidence Base for the new scheme

The Council appointed external consultants to model our current housing to analyse the private rented sector.

  • to introduce a selective licensing scheme, the area must have proportion of PRS that is significantly greater than the national average of 19% (source: English House Condition Survey, published December 2022)
WardDwellings - all stockCount (Dwellings - private rented)Percentage (Dwellings - private rented)
Belvedere7,2492,33432%
Erith5,3921,60330%
Sidcup7,1972,11029%
Thamesmead East6,5241,73627%
Slade Green & Northend5,3121,38026%
Crayford6,8931,40320%
Longlands4,43687920%
Bexleyheath6,5541,29120%
Crook Log6,4741,25619%
Falconwood & Welling6,4581,18518%
St Mary's & St James4,66584518%
East Wickham6,28096615%
Northumberland Heath4,24660114%
Barnehurst4,71166414%
Blackfen & Lamorbey6,59192414%
Blendon & Penhill6,26980313%
West Heath6,1385218%
  • there are nine wards in Bexley that are above the national PRS average and so could be considered for selective licensing
  • crook Log is only just above 19%, so it cannot be argued that it is significantly above the national average and should not be considered
  • this means there are 8 wards that could be considered for selective licensing-Belvedere, Bexleyheath, Crayford, Erith, Longlands, Slade Green & Northend, Sidcup and Thamesmead East

The next stage is to consider those Wards with the highest PRS against the two identified objectives for a Selective Licensing Regime:

The first objective of the scheme is to improve property conditions

  • 8% of PRS properties in Bexley have Category 1 hazards. To be included in a Selective Licensing Regime, the designated area should be either be the equal to or above this figure
WardNumber of dwellings - Private rented propertiesHHSRS Category 1 Hazards
Belvedere2,334 (32%)181 (8%)
Erith1,603 (30%)97 (6%)
Sidcup2,110 (29%)176 (8%)
Thamesmead East1,736 (27%)74 (4%)
Slade Green & Northend1,380 (26%)82 (6%)
Crayford1,403 (20%)108 (8%)
Longlands879 (20%)72 (8%)
Bexleyheath1,291 (20%)105 (8%)
  • Erith (6%), Slade Green and Northend (6%) and Thamesmead East (4%) are all below this figure and so should not be considered for selective licensing because these areas are not suffering with poor property conditions and therefore do not meet the statutory requirement
  • Belvedere, Sidcup, Crayford, Longlands and Bexleyheath remain as possible Wards for potential designation

The second objective of the scheme is to improve ASB in the affected areas

WardNumber of ASB incidents - 2020Number of ASB incidents - 2021Number of ASB incidents - 2022
Barnehurst325186110
Belvedere670505286
Bexleyheath525538344
Blackfen & Lamorbey382273176
Blendon & Penhill31719673
Crayford696489257
Crook Log491284137
East Wickham456259153
Erith549455232
Falconwood & Welling467295152
Longlands330250113
Northumberland Heath359219138
Sidcup490331168
Slade Green & Northend409297250
St Mary's & St James326254121
Thamesmead East646521247
West Heath223160144
  • the evidence (source – Met Police data) does not show Sidcup and Longlands Wards as having disproportionate ASB compared to other areas
  • Belvedere, Bexleyheath and Crayford are amongst the wards most affected by ASB.
  • However, when reviewing the ASB at 'Lower Super Output Area' level, the data highlights that the highest area within Crayford and Bexleyheath are the town centres with their high proportions of late-night venues and drinking establishments. The ASB in the town centres is likely due to people travelling to those areas and not necessarily due to people living directly within the areas. When looking at the ward areas away from the town centres, the ASB is significantly lower.  It is therefore unlikely that the elevated ASB in those Wards is a result of the PRS housing. Therefore, introducing a licensing scheme in these wards will have limited impact on addressing ASB
  • Belvedere Ward shows elevated ASB across of the Ward

It is proposed that a new selective licensing scheme covers Belvedere ward:

Increase in people renting accommodation

  • in the last decade, there has been an increase in people renting accommodation, which makes this scheme to improve conditions in the PRS and to regulate landlords even more important
  • in 2021, based on data from the English Housing Conditions Survey 62.5% of households in England & Wales owned the accommodation they lived in, 37.3% rented their accommodation (20.3% private and 17.1% social) and 0.1% of households lived rent free. Since 2011, there has been a fall of ownership (almost 2 percentage points), an increase in renting (3 percentage points) and a fall in households living rent free (from 1.4% to 0.1%)
    Before introducing a selective licensing scheme, the council is required to carry out a consultation.  The consultation must run for a minimum of 10 weeks. After the consultation we must consider the key issues raised and provide a response

Before introducing a selective licensing scheme, the council is required to carry out a consultation.  The consultation must run for a minimum of 10 weeks. After the consultation, we must consider the key issues raised and provide a response.

7. Possible mitigating actions

Please detail how any potential negative impacts for each equality's groups could reasonably be addressed?

If possible, please indicate what you think the likely cost of mitigation would be.

Answer

Once we have analysed data on the profile of people in PRS within the Belvedere Ward - if we discover there isn’t sufficient data on any protected groups. We will consider how we can capture this information and use it to inform the development of this scheme.

Enforcement action will only be taken in line with the Housing Standards Enforcement policy, which means that action must be proportionate and reasonable. The first approach will be advice and guidance.

The intention is to survey tenants and residents within the proposed Selective Licensing scheme throughout the scheme’s implementation. This will help to monitor its impact on people with protected characteristics and provide equalities data which can be used to develop the scheme.

When taking enforcement action, we will look to collect equalities data on individual Landlords to understand if there is any impact on any protected group.